HOME
MOVIES
TV Shows
In Theatres
SEARCH
FRESH
QUEUE
Your Sisters Sister
2012
MOVIE IS
excellent
dramatic
romantic
artificial
naturalistic
Close Video
watch now
Reviews
similar movies
cast & crew
tags
63 %
83 %
Certified Fresh
$ 3 Million
See Where to Watch
Your Sisters Sister
Positive Reviews
104
Negative reviews
5
Average Rating
3.7
/5
excellent
dramatic
romantic
artificial
naturalistic
All
Positive
Negative
2.8
This time out, Shelton seems to be playing the part of someone who doesnt know how to finish what she started.
Av Club
4.2
Theres an exciting dynamic tension in the shifting triangular relationships and a magical alchemy among the players.
EW
3.8
This series of scenes, semi improvised like a lot of the movie, has a natural quality that gets everything said and yet doesnt feel like dialogue.
Rogerebert
4.0
Behavior a mixture of scripted action and improvisation springs from a natural place, and while that can be uncomfortable as well as funny, it never r ..
Common Sense Media
4.2
When Your Sisters Sister dips into formula, replete with tired confrontations and sentimental monologues, it loses some of its raw energy.
Indie Wire
4.5
The three leads are pitch perfect here, loose and low key yet fully in character.
Variety
4.0
Your Sisters Sister is a fine piece of character observation. Its low key, casual, and tremendously insightful. It wont be for everybody, but thats a ..
We Got This Covered
4.0
This film should come with a warning: dont watch with a sibling. Unless youre up for some knowing elbow digs.
Time Out
4.0
Barring some late inning coyness, its some of the truest, dinged heart couples circling of the year.
Time Out
3.1
Which isnt to say that we dont form a relationship with these creatures.
3.8
Its a tribute to Shelton and her cast that theyve made a film about the difficulties of love, friends and family look so easy.
4.5
Loktevs slow burning film is fit for the art house, but, like a long hike, it rewards careful, patient attention.
Vulture
4.5
Venue: Toronto International Film Festival Production Company: ADA Films LLC.
The Hollywood Reporter
3.0
However, theres also no doubt that the characters solitary focus on their personal needs leads, inevitably, to a solipsistic quality that, for the the ..
3.6
Yes, the sisters relationship is at stake, but Jack doesnt seem worth the fuss.
Paste Magazine
2.5
It gets you sick to see a good bike ruined by awful screenwriting.
San Francisco Chronicle
4.5
A quiet and well told movie that wears its big beating heart on its sleeve.
Cinema Blend
4.0
The dialogue was largely improvised during a 12 day shoot, and the chemistry between the leads appears effortless.
Ny Daily News
4.0
By the time its over, you dont really want to leave and the ninety minute run time just whizzes by.
JoBlo
3.8
Shelton and her cast are so skillful that before long it seems we are not moviegoers watching a screen but flies on a wall witnessing real encounters ..
Philly
4.0
A romantic comedy about two sisters and their friend with three top drawer and dazzling performances.
Spirituality And Practice
2.5
As artificial as a Hollywood rom.com... With a different cast, a bigger budget, and some punched up dialogue, it might have been made by Judd Apatow.
One Guys Opinion
2.5
So if we must bury mumblecore as a genre, lets acknowledge that Your Sisters Sister is all of its shortcomings in a nutshell good actors and bursts of ..
Rogers Movie Nation
3.8
Perfectly fine somewhere between the humor of discomfort and that brutality of the truth, sustaining its feel for family and the bond between loved on ..
Blu Ray
4.5
Our reporters scour Chicago in search of whats new, whats now, and whats next.
Chicago Reader
3.1
Places too much external pressure on the characters; the conflict is already there.
Mark Reviews Movies
3.5
But Your Sisters Sister is a better movie because it doesnt ring false.
5.0
Your Sisters Sister feels like a new flavor of fruit, one with a complex taste that is never artificial, bland or too sweet.
Usa Today
3.8
It doesnt hurt, either, that Fresnadillo offers up a genuinely thrilling set piece about halfway through involving Johns first encounter with Mias pur ..
Reel Film Reviews
2.8
Jack doesnt want to get between the two sisters and cause more of a rift than he already has.
Lariat
3.8
When it comes time for the frowny aftermath, Sheltons heart isnt in it.
Eric Ds Nider
3.8
Your Sisters Sister works its way into your head until you cant stop thinking about it.
Rolling Stone
4.5
Sheltons empathy for the characters bleeds through, even at their worst moments.
The Wrap
4.0
Lynn Sheltons follow up to Humpday is an engagingly spiky, pleasingly unconventional comedy drama with a strong script and a trio of terrific performa ..
View London
2.5
Your Sisters Sister is convinced of its own depth but ultimately feels superficial rather like its inexplicable title.
News Day
3.5
In the good variety, the mumbling is witty and expressive, and the mumblers worth listening to.
Cs Monitor
3.8
Shelton (who also cast Duplass in the insufferable smug Humpday) doesnt always place the camera for maximum dramatic effect and takes very limited adv ..
New York Post
3.8
Your Sisters Sister proceeds with dramatic (if not real world) logic and humor and the sort of openhearted earnestness that doesnt preclude satire.
Boston
4.5
Its not just that hes refreshingly against the usual male lead type.
Mountain X
4.5
Duplass is doing his conflicted mumblecore thing quite elegantly these days, and hes joined here by Blunts fragile Iris and DeWitts alternately guarde ..
Npr
4.4
Even when things get a little crazy and maybe even too soapy, Your Sisters Sister always feels like its rooted in a tangible reality, a place of unpre ..
Star Tribune
3.8
A small indie with a big heart, Sheltons character study is a more mature and subtle feature than Humpday.
Emanuellevy
4.0
The naturalism of the performances provides the films charm a giggle from Blunt, tears from the excellent DeWitt and with the improvisations evident i ..
Guardian
3.0
Much makes the viewer feel theyre a fly on the wall, albeit a fly who has difficulty holding the camera steady or staying in focus.
Guardian
4.0
A lovely example of what a surefooted filmmaker can achieve with a game and talented cast and a generous, heartfelt story demonstrable proof that smal ..
Guardian
4.5
By that time, we care about the characters enough that were willing to overlook a far fetched implausibility or two.
Slate
3.0
A very genuine film packed with smart observations about modern relationships.
Flim List
3.5
The up side of this is that theres a freshness to the performances that boosts the immersive aspect of the story.
Eye For Film
4.5
The observations are real and theres an honesty about the dialogue exchanged between sisters, best friends and new acquaintances.
2.5
The jabber is maddening, but with all due respect, the actors are wonderful, the performances as natural as inhaling. Still, in Emily Blunts case, the ..
Observer
4.5
All three performers add both tone and, when required, a fierce volume to their interplay.
New Yorker
3.8
Your Sisters Sister gets it just right, aided by Vince Smiths string accented musical score and Benjamin Kasulkes luscious cinematography.
Boston Herald
3.0
The acting in Your Sisters Sister is also top notch and reason enough to see it, especially if youre a fan of the lovely Emily Blunt.
Express
3.1
Its pleasant as far as it goes. For all the blithe interaction among the central three performers, however, the materials conventional and predictable ..
Chicago Tribune
4.0
Duplass is wonderful but even he cant shine as brightly as Emily Blunt.
The Irish Times
4.5
...a deft blending of comedy and drama. It may not be the most credible film of the year, but I found it diverting and enjoyable.
Blogs Indie Wire
3.0
An effortless, emotional, funny little indie that few people will see. Be one of them.
Total Film
4.2
Effective evidence that the emotional immediacy in the halting rhythms of extemporaneous speech can often trump the art of the well chosen word. A fil ..
The Atlantic
1.5
...chick flick city...a mnage trois lite...agonizing to watch poor Emily Blunt laugh uproariously at contrived, slice of life conversation made with h ..
Tony Medley
3.2
Mumblecore standard bearer Lynn Shelton (Humpday) shows promising signs of maturing with an originally executed romantic comedy.
Coles Mithey
4.2
It certainly shows that fine films dont need big budgets, capturing some sweet lightning in an arresting bottle indeed.
Detroit News
4.0
Thats the basic premise of a movie that comes off as a lighter, fluffier and female friendly version of a Judd Apatow comedy that doesnt necessarily t ..
3.5
Right from the get go, this indie American talkfest exudes a confidence, a composure and, dare I say it, a cool that extinguishes any cynicism in the ..
Herald Sun
3.1
And I dont mind saying that loud and clearly, without any mumbling at all.
Nj
4.0
Your Sisters Sister rises above its simplistic conceit to become a smart, perceptive and witty three hander that explores some deep issues while maint ..
Hey U Guys
4.4
Its a hopeful, upbeat film about people finding comfort and strength in their loved ones, a rare feel good movie that truly earns that designation.
Film School Rejects
4.5
Its in the completely natural interactions between this gifted cast that the film really hits its groove.
Film Ink
3.5
Deceptively meandering and unexpectedly complex, Your Sisters Sister combines a poignant, funny directness with a teasing incompleteness.
The Age
3.0
Wisely, Shelton invites Humpdays Mark Duplass back for another light hearted, well meaning romp.
The Age
3.0
Hes grouchy but witty, selfish yet sensitive, and he doesnt overplay any of them.
Cine Vue
4.0
The story unfolds subtly and without apparent effort, but its the humour that provides the warmth and, combined with fabulous and endearing performanc ..
Nz Herald
4.0
One of the most purely pleasurable grown up films Ive seen this year.
Flicks
3.8
Yes, Sister smoothes over some complicated conflicts and feelings, but it also doesnt wallow.
Red Eye Chicago
4.0
Like a cool breeze, there is a light and fluffy feel to Your Sisters Sister that makes it the perfect palate cleanser in the middle of a hot, sweaty s ..
Stl Today
3.1
Hannah doesnt know Jack very well outside of what Iris has told her, but she graciously invites him to stay.
Dustin Put Man
1.5
Shelton has such sharp timing that its hard to believe that each scene isnt carefully planned, instead of discovered in the moment.
Hollywood And Fine
4.0
But the surrounding drama doesnt detract from how absolutely, singularly enjoyable it is just to spend time with these characters their interactions a ..
The Arts Desk
2.5
Dont be surprised if you find yourself nodding off mid movie, bored silly by a trio of good actors stuck in a dull scenario about a young man caught i ..
Patriot Ledger
4.2
Their first encounter is rather confrontational but it doesnt take long for Jack and Hannah to start enjoying each others company.
The Film Pie
4.4
But the result doesnt feel polished; it feels fresh and heartfelt.
Js Online
3.5
DeWitt is spectacular here, making one wonder why on Earth she doesnt get more roles.
Hollywood Chicago
4.5
Beautifully simple and downright extraordinary thanks to a cast that truly understands what Shelton and their characters want, and then go above and b ..
Shockya
3.0
There is so much good in the first hour that you can just about forgive its poorly written third act.
What Culture
3.0
Shelton is a wonder with actors and she mines some gold from this sitcom setup DeWitt, in particular, showcases a spiky comic deftness.
The Skinny
4.5
Suffice it to say that Your Sisters Sister is an uncommonly smart and complicated romantic comedy, one that gets the laugh but doesnt look away from t ..
Dvd Talk
4.5
Your Sisters Sister is a very sweet, very human feature that is also very, very funny. Much hay is made out of Mark Duplass reaction shots, and thats ..
Streaming Quickflix
4.5
was shot in a mere 12 days, on a budget that must have been minuscule. A couple of minutes after its started, though, you know youre in the presence o ..
Wsj
3.8
Theres a special satisfaction in hearing characters speak as if they just had arrived on the screen from the coffee shop adjacent to the movie theater ..
Clclt
4.5
Unusually for a romance (albeit an unconventional one), it doesnt privilege boy girl love over all others.
Bfi
3.0
Tangled relationships aside, Your Sisters Sister is a straightforward character driven drama bolstered by a lean, unsentimental script and given an ed ..
Fan The Fire Magazine
4.5
Blunt never seems more at home than when shes crisply snapping out zingers, but there is nothing zingy about Iris.
Entertainment Time
4.5
A wonderfully funny and uncharacteristically easy take on a genre that has been in disrepair for some time.
Trespass Mag
3.1
The improvisational style doesnt come close to HBOs Curb Your Enthusiasm or Christopher Guests A Mighty Wind and Best in Show.
Entertainment Spectrum
3.1
The sisters are merely agents in Jacks maturation in what is ultimately a Judd Apatow film on a microbudget.
Boston Phoenix
1.5
I couldnt figure out what Ivy sees in Jack at all and he isnt able to give the audience that oh, thats why we should be rooting for this guy!
Wp Me
4.5
Its rare to find a film so heavy on the naturalistic realism that feels so effortless and unpretentious.
Sky
3.5
The performance of Mark Duplass, who could be called Mr. Mumblecore for specializing in low budget indies, is the reason to see this.
Compuserve
4.0
No question that Shelton and her cast share a remarkable collaborative rapport.
MSN Movies
4.0
Finally, the writer director has become known for effacing a high concept plotline with naturalistic performances and shooting styles.
Movie Line
4.0
Hollywood rom coms could certainly do with such a breath of fresh air.
Cinema Autopsy
4.5
Its an oddly charming and entertaining film that works because its willing to embrace the less savory side of its characters.
Kc Active
2.5
Lynn Sheltons fourth feature after her well received Humpday demands more patience than understanding.
Monsters And Critics
3.8
In the very best sense, Your Sisters Sister almost feels like its being made up as it goes along: organic, fluent and true. (
Blog Oregonlive
3.1
For a film that relies on conversation and connection, its awfully plot heavy, full of Aha! dramatic revelations that feel more suited to a soap opera ..
Host Madison
3.8
Enjoyable but surprisingly conventional contemporary (i.e., sexually frank) romantic comedy...
Commercial Appeal (Memphis ..
4.3
Watching mortals sort through relationships is not just an intelligent way to spend an afternoon its downright refreshing. The characters are so hones ..
Womens Voices For Change
1.5
I think I need a break from Mark Duplass for awhile. At least, from the Mark Duplass who isnt arguing about fantasy football with Ruxin and Taco.
Technology Tell
4.4
We might not know exactly what either of these women sees in the unemployed, underripe Jack. But theyre winning enough for the audience to hope they g ..
3.1
Even amidst the excessive chatter, Emily Blunt shines most of all.
Advocate (Baton Rouge, LA) ..
3.0
This lo fi comedy is big on charm but was a little too shaggy for my taste.
The Crat
4.3
Director Shelton just keeps getting better. An interpersonal drama, the storys offset with elements of a modern sex farce, blending and sculpting the ..
3.8
Honest and free spirited, this romantic comedy is filled with genuine and uncomfortable moments that can only come when a trio of talented actors ... ..
Toronto Star
1.5
Humpday showed that Shelton has talent, particularly as a director of actors, but Your Sisters Sister is a disappointing follow up.
Gay City News
3.0
The films strength is in its realistic improvisation, like a window on three, average lives in a cocoon for a brief moment that will be easily forgott ..
Real.com
2.5
When the heartfelt professions of love and soul unloading declarations of betterment are emulsified down to mush, all that remains is a swiftly evapor ..
3.0
A little too quiet and slow in places, Your Sisters Sister is warm and touching with three great lead performances.
4.5
Its comforting to watching dramatic and comic fiction regarding the things some of us actually have to deal with in life. When done right, those kinds ..
See Where to Watch
Your Sisters Sister